Can I get an STI from a sex toy? YES you can! You can also get other infections if the sex toys you use aren't cleaned properly. Because toys are made of My medical tidbits STDs you can catch without sex HPV.the human papillomavirus which is transmitted by skin to skin contact, mother to baby by pregnancy, labor, or nursing, and sex (of course) Can using sex toys lead to sexually transmitted infections? HealthShots Here are some ways to help prevent sexually transmitted infections (STIs): Engage in safer sex or activities that avoid contact with your partner's bodily fluids. Use condoms correctly. Get Can You Get an STD if Both Partners Have No STDs?